Booty HuntAn atlas of lost treasure

Searching for the flagship’s name

Two wreck attributions compete in the story of Nuestra Señora de la Regla, the fleet commander’s ship.

Nuestra Senora de la Regla (?)Partially salvagedEstimated location
Illustrative engraving of a galleon in stormy seas
Illustrative engraving. Not a documentary reconstruction of this vessel.

The account collected for Regla describes a ship crushed on a reef and the death of commander Ubilla. Its cargo is described in rich detail, including silver coins and other valuables.

Connecting that documented ship to a modern site is harder. The research records a tentative association with the Cabin Wreck, but another source proposes Corrigan’s wreck. The map’s zone spans the candidate areas rather than quietly choosing one.

What remains uncertain

The location is estimated and the attribution disputed. The evidence does not yet justify a precise marker labelled as the flagship.

The dashed zone is an estimate, not a wreck position.

Open the evidence

The research record is preserved below, including attribution, disagreements, and uncertainty.

Cargo, with attribution
~1,300 chests containing 3,000,000 silver coins, plus gold coins and bars, silver bars, jewelry, emeralds, pearls and Kangxi porcelain (de Bry, citing AGI Consulados 854).
Discovery and recovery
partially salvaged (Cabin Wreck: first 1715 site found/salvaged by Kip Wagner & Real Eight, 1960s); attribution disputed
Confidence in the record
low-medium - de Bry calls Cabin Wreck the only site identifiable 'with a certain degree of accuracy', but Corrigan's is still proposed for Regla.
Location evidence
Opposite the Sebastian (Ays) River; Cabin Wreck 'about two miles south of the Sebastian Inlet' (de Bry). Alternative attribution: Corrigan's wreck ~5 mi N of Vero Beach city limits (1715 Fleet Society glossary).
ESTIMATE: point = Sebastian Inlet SP coordinate moved 2 statute mi along the coast azimuth (Sebastian Inlet SP -> Fort Pierce Inlet SP), per de Bry's text. Not a site fix.
Original identification and research notes

Nuestra Senora de la Regla (Ubilla's capitana, New Spain flota) - tentatively the Cabin Wreck (8IR23)

Romans' 1774 map note: 'opposite this River, perished the Admiral commanding the Plate Fleet 1715' (quoted by de Bry).

Elongated zone spanning both candidate sites (Cabin estimate and Corrigan's published point), 1.5 km half-width; coast-parallel because of shoreward storm drive.

Protected history

Florida state-owned submerged lands (within 3 mi): state title to abandoned historic wrecks under Fla. Stat. ch. 267 and the federal Abandoned Shipwreck Act of 1987 [nps.gov]; recovery only under state permit/contract (FAC 1A-31). Possible relevance (analyst note, not a sourced claim): Spain has asserted sovereign immunity over sunken state vessels elsewhere (see San Jose 1708); no Spanish claim to this specific site was found in the sources used.

Follow the sources

These are the references supplied with this record. Some describe historical claims or disputed interpretations rather than settled conclusions.

  1. 1715fleetsociety.comSource 1
  2. 1715fleetsociety.comSource 2
  3. darktiderelics.comSource 3
  4. en.wikipedia.orgSource 4
  5. en.wikipedia.orgSource 5